Indie SaaS Founders Struggle with Low Revenue and Marketing Effectiveness
Reddit Community
Community Problem
Elevator Pitch
Many indie SaaS founders, despite building functional products, fail to gain traction and achieve profitability due to ineffective marketing and demand validation, indicating a need for better go-to-market strategies.
Full Description
Early 2024 I couldn't escape Tony Dinh, levelsio, Marc Lou on X. Started thinking: maybe I could actually do this.
My first attempt was VarNamer, an AI variable naming tool built with Electron + Vue3. Actually got some decent feedback, then Cursor came out and just obliterated it overnight. I was out $99 for an Apple dev cert. Never touched it again. Fine, lesson learned. Don't build desktop apps for something that should be web.
The Spark
I got the idea for Chat2Report (a financial statement analysis tool) because I'm a value investor (Peter Lynch/Buffett style) and reading 100-page 10-Ks was brutal. The tools that were out there tried to do everything: news, earnings calls, ratings. The RAG was honestly bad. I wanted something dead simple. Just financial statements, analyzed properly.
Late 2024 I quit my job. My wife and I had a serious conversation about it first. I went all in. Backend was Go + Gin, Python + LlamaIndex + FastAPI for the LLM layer, Vue3 frontend. Took about three months.
After Launch
After launching, I tried everything. Twitter, LinkedIn, Facebook. Basically zero signups. Paid for backlinks, automated Twitter. Nothing. Google Ads got me two paying users, one monthly, one yearly. The moment I paused ads, everything went dead.
Fell right into the classic trap of "if I just add more features." I kept coding instead of marketing. A few more users trickled in. Almost a year later, revenue was under $300. Not even covering server costs.
What I Learned
Couple things I learned. Speed beats perfection. My clean code obsession delayed the launch by weeks. Marketing is 80% of it and I was bad at it and didn't really want to do it. Should've validated demand before quitting.
Similar stuff existed but I never actually talked to potential users. Also having a supportive spouse matters a lot. And yeah, traditional jobs aren't forever-safe, but going indie with no runway is stressful.
What's Next
In March I'm going back to a normal job. Chat2Report will keep evolving since I still think the vision is solid, but next time I'll be smarter. Side project first, validate hard, quit later.
If you're thinking about quitting for your first SaaS, I don't think there's a universal answer. If you've validated demand and have 6 to 12 months of runway, sure. If not, maybe don't.
Question for the community
Curious what other people's experience was. Did you quit for a SaaS? What worked or didn't? Would especially love to hear from anyone who also made basically nothing their first year.
Get involved
Discussion
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts.
From the Reddit thread(7 top comments)
- 30·Reddit commenter·1mo ago
Respect for going all in. That takes guts. Two patterns usually break projects like this: 1) Building a better 10-K analyzer doesn’t create demand. Retail investors don’t wake up wanting a new tool. They follow voices. If you didn’t own an audience in value investing before launch, Google Ads becomes the only oxygen, and that’s expensive. 2) Reading 100-page filings feels painful to us, but most retail investors either skim, rely on summaries, or don’t read them at all. If the pain isn’t sharp and frequent, they won’t pay monthly. The signal here isn’t that you failed. It’s that th…
permalink ↗ - 14·Reddit commenter·1mo ago·reply
>Retail investors don’t wake up wanting a new tool. They follow voices. People like trashing the influencer world, but there's a *reason* it has value. Anyone who has tried to sell a product or a service or anything understands that. It's extremely hard to build up enough of a following that people will follow your voice, actions, etc. Whether it's tech or music - building an audience is an under-respected skill.
permalink ↗ - 13·Reddit commenter·1mo ago
The Tony Dinh / Levelsio rabbit hole is real and it gets a lot of people. The survivorship bias in indie hacker content is brutal — you see the success stories but not the thousands of people who built something nobody wanted. One thing that jumps out: a 10-K analyzer is a tool for people who already have a workflow. Value investors already have their process, and convincing them to change it is almost impossible. It's different from solving a pain point people are actively complaining about. Something that helped us figure out our niche: instead of asking "who would use this?" we started lo…
permalink ↗ - 7·Reddit commenter·1mo ago
The Tony Dinh / levelsio rabbit hole got me too. What saved me was shifting from "build something cool" to "who has this problem badly enough to pay today" — sounds obvious but most of us skip it. One year with <$300 hurts, but honestly the founders who push through that first reality check are the ones who eventually figure it out. What's your plan from here?
permalink ↗ - 7·Reddit commenter·1mo ago
Appreciate you sharing this honestly. most people only post the wins biggest issue: you never talked to potential users before building. financial analysis is a real pain point but you assumed the solution without validating anyone would pay the marketing reality is brutal but accurate. 80% marketing, 20% product. most devs hate this but it's true what you got right: \- supportive spouse (underrated) \- actually launching \- going back to a job instead of burning savings what might've worked: \- side project first while employed \- talk to 20-30 value investors before writing cod…
permalink ↗ - 6·Reddit commenter·1mo ago
the 'marketing is 80%' insight is right, but what it actually means is: find people who already have the pain before you build. the market pull problem you hit -- investors didn't wake up wanting a better 10-K tool -- that's the real signal. demand validation beats demand creation every time at this stage.
permalink ↗ - 5·Reddit commenter·1mo ago
Man this hits close to home. Seriously respect you for sharing this so openly. The part about marketing being 80% of it and not wanting to do it, that's literally the trap we almost fell into too. We're building a SaaS right now and the first few months we did exactly what you described. Posted on Twitter, LinkedIn, tried some paid stuff. Crickets. What changed everything for us was Reddit honestly. Not in a "post your link and pray" way, that gets you banned instantly. More like actually spending time in the subreddits where our target users hang out, answering questions, being helpful, and…
permalink ↗