SaaS companies face stock devaluation despite strong performance due to AI narrative shifts.
Reddit Community
Community Problem
Elevator Pitch
Public SaaS companies are experiencing significant stock price drops despite positive revenue and retention, as market narratives around AI disruption overshadow actual performance, creating a valuation crisis for established software providers.
Full Description
We're a public SaaS company. Won't say which one but the pattern is the same across dozens of us.
Revenue growth: +23% YoY. Net retention: 112%. Customer count: up 18%. Every operating metric trending positive.
Stock price: down 45% from January highs. Down 60% from 2024 peak.
The explanation I keep hearing is "AI will replace you." Analysts ask about our AI strategy on every earnings call. They want to know how Claude Cowork or AI agents will disrupt our business model. Doesn't matter that we've integrated AI into our product. Doesn't matter that customers are using it. The narrative is that AI kills traditional SaaS and our multiple should compress.
What I've realized is that public markets price narratives, not performance. We can execute perfectly and still see the stock crater because the story changed. The story used to be "SaaS is recurring revenue with compounding growth." The new story is "AI agents will replace per-seat software."
For founders considering going public: understand that once you're public, your fate is partially determined by narratives you don't control. The SaaSpocalypse wiped a trillion dollars from software stocks based on demos and announcements, not actual revenue impact.
Get involved
Discussion
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts.
From the Reddit thread(11 top comments)
- 66·Reddit commenter·1mo ago
honestly this is why I tell founders to stay private as long as possible, public markets are basically a casino where your business fundamentals matter way less than whatever story Wall Street is obsessed with that quarter. You're doing everything right but the market decided AI is the boogeyman this year, next year it'll be something else and your stock will randomly moon when some analyst changes the narrative back
permalink ↗ - 43·Reddit commenter·1mo ago
Many saas companies spent the last 2 years saying how AI is replacing their employees then wonder why the market thinks AI will replace the whole company
permalink ↗ - 14·Reddit commenter·1mo ago
Imagine that the stock has been overvalued in the first place. What if it is close to its real value now? It might still be overvalued even after being down. Can you share what is the P/E ratio?
permalink ↗ - 9·Reddit commenter·1mo ago
You nailed it with narratives. Public markets price the future story more than the present metrics. The irony is many SaaS companies are still growing well, but the narrative shift toward AI agents compresses multiples regardless of operational performance.
permalink ↗ - 9·Reddit commenter·1mo ago
That post earnings drop was the most nonsensical move...pretty sure I have the right company in mind. Beat and a raise...so clearly we need to discount the stock further to 3.5 sales. As others in this thread have suggested, I think there are a lot of private credit funds panic selling. Honestly...I'm struggling big time right now because the distance between what others say they're getting out of these tools, and what we're getting out of these tools is huge...like to the point where I feel like I'm just not getting it. FWIW - Last time I felt this way, everyone was telling me that the b…
permalink ↗ - 9·Reddit commenter·1mo ago·reply
In fairness, it was really only the companies that either over hired, are in distress, or run by Jack Dorsey. No matter which one it is, there's good reason to be skeptical about the motivations around layoffs.
permalink ↗ - 6·Reddit commenter·1mo ago·reply
You end up chasing market trends every quarter to keep stakeholders happy
permalink ↗ - 6·Reddit commenter·1mo ago·reply
Like they have an option. There have been close to 0 SaaS IPOs last year Edit: 6 out of 164 to be exact
permalink ↗ - 5·Reddit commenter·1mo ago
I think SaaSpocalypse is driven by funds reallocating their longterm investments. They don’t care that the business is still growing and profitable, but if the trend indicates that within 10-20 years this business is dead they are selling. I think this is what we are seeing.
permalink ↗ - 5·Reddit commenter·1mo ago·reply
Most of the stocks in this group are around 20X forward now. Yes, they were all over valued before the blowout.
permalink ↗ - 5·Reddit commenter·1mo ago
I work in finance. It’s crazy but fundamentals (actual revenue, retention, etc) have nearly zero influence on stock price now if you are a so-called growth company. The only thing that matters is your growth forecast (and the degree to which investors think it is real or bullshit).
permalink ↗